1900 Broadway, New York, NY 10023 (212) 595-5330
1900 Broadway, New York, NY 10023 (212) 595-5330
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Menus

All Day Menu

Download PDF

Fresh Baked Whole Italian Loaf

  • Plain Loaf

    $6

  • Garlic Spread

    $10

  • Truffle Spread

    $12

Charcuterie Board

for the table

  • for the table

    Prosciutto Di Parma, Mortadella, Hot Sopressata, Salami Finocchiona, Housemade Burrata Mozzarella, Parmigiano Reggiano, Grissini

    $42

Vegetable Antipasto Bar

three vegetables $28.00 | five vegetables $38.00

  • cauliflower milanese

    herb breaded cauliflower

  • Sicilian Eggplant Caponata

    tomato, capers, olives, raisins

  • Puff Pastry Vegetable Tart

    seasonal veggies & ricotta cheese

  • Roasted Brussels Sprouts

    parmigiano cheese

  • Stuffed Peppers

    capers, olives, and Tuscan bread

  • Fava Bean Salad

    shaved pecorino

  • Sausage & Peppers

  • Grilled Zucchini & Peppers Medley

  • Broccoli Rabe Aglio e Oilio

  • Mushroom Trifolati

    oyster, portobello, crimini, garlic

  • roasted heirloom carrots

  • Marinated Olives & Shaved Parmigiano

  • Ricotta Cheese Balls

    pomodoro sauce

  • Truffle Potato Pie

    mushroom cream

  • Stuffed Artichoke

    herbed breadcrumb

  • lentils and sweet corn

    aged balsamic, fresh tomato

  • grilled asparagus

    extra virgin oil, sea salt

  • butternut squash lasagna

    bechamel, parmigiano cheese

Shareable Appetizers

to share

  • Tomato Goat-Cheese Bruschetta

    $18

  • Italian Wedding Soup

    chicken sausage meatball

    $18

  • Italian Sausage & Roasted Peppers

    $17

  • Short Rib Meatballs

    two $12

    four $22

  • Fried Calamari

    hot cherry pepper

    $20

  • Crab Cakes

    lemon aioli

    $20

  • Roman Fried Artichokes alla Giudia

    $26

  • Proscuitto with Burrata

    $25

Salads


add chicken paillard $15
add grilled salmon $19
add grilled shrimp $16

  • Marilena Arugula Salad

    truffle cheese, grapes, walnut, arugula, romaine, radicchio

    $19.50

  • little gem caesar

    brioche croutons

    $19.50

  • caprese salad

    burrata mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, pesto

    $19

  • quinoa & avocado salad

    orange, cucumber, dried currants, almonds

    $19

  • chicken cobb salad

    avocado, bacon, blue cheese, tomato, egg

    $34

  • beet salad

    frisee, arugula, goat cheese roasted pistachio

    $19

Our Signature Thin Crust Pizza

gluten-free pizza crust add $6.00

  • Margherita

    burrata mozzarella, pomodoro, basil

    $28

  • A lot of Pepperoni

    'nduja sausage, spicy honey

    $30

  • Four Seasons

    mushroom, artichoke, roasted pepper, pesto

    $30

  • Prosciutto Di Parma

    arugula, parmesan, burrata mozzarella

    $30

  • Sweet Fennel Sausage & Roasted Peppers

    burrata mozzarella

    $29

  • Diavola Pizza

    $31

  • Alla Vodka

    Vodka Sauce, Fiore di Latte

    $30

Pasta

whole wheat or gluten free pasta available

  • Rigatoni alla Vodka

    guanciale bacon, breadcrumbs

    $29

  • Spaghetti cacio e pepe with fried artichokes

    $30

  • Orecchiette with Sausage and Broccoli Rabe

    $29

  • Fettucine Bolognese

    pork ragu

    $29

  • Housemade Ravioli with Burrata Mozzarella

    $28

  • Spaghetti & Short Rib Meatballs

    $30

  • Linguini Pescatore

    mussels, clams, shrimp, scallops, calamari, lobster tomato broth

    $44

  • NEW Fiorello Lasagna

    shortrib beef, meatball, burrata

    $39

  • linguini with clams

    spinach linguini, roasted grape tomato, garlic, breadcrumbs

    $33

  • strozzapreti al pesto

    basil peso, pine nuts

    $28

  • Sea Scallops with Mushroom Risotto

    asparagus, porcini mushroom

    $44

Sea

  • Faroe Island Salmon

    sicilian ratatouille crust, spinach

    $39

  • mediterranean branzino al forno

    charred peppers, onions, olives

    $41

  • Dover Sole

    lemon beurre blanc, asparagus

    petit $39

    regular $57

  • Shrimp Scampi

    tuscan beans, arugula, bacon

    $37

  • Sea Scallops with Mushroom Risotto

    asparagus, porcini mushroom

    $44

Land

add a half order of five pomodoro spaghetti to your entree $13

  • Classic Chicken Parmigiana

    burrata mozzarella

    $38

  • Chicken pepperoni parmigiana

    burrata mozzarella

    $39

  • Chicken Parmigiana alla vodka

    burrata mozzarella

    $39

  • Lemon Chicken Picatta

    artichoke, capers, beurre blanc

    $31

  • Chicken Scaloppine Marsala

    porcini mushrooms

    $33

  • Eggplant Parmigiana

    $30

  • Veal Cutlet Parmigiana

    burrata mozzarella

    $41

  • Veal Cutlet Pepperoni Parmigiana

    burrata mozzarella

    $42

  • Veal Cutlet Milanese

    tomatoes, basil, arugula

    $40

  • Cafe Fiorello Prime Black Label Cheeseburger

    tillamook cheddar cheese, cacio e pepe fries

    $28

  • Filet Mignon

    pecorino polenta, peppers & onions

    $55

Our Famous Lamb & Veal Chops

  • Veal Chop Parmigiana

    burrata mozzarella

    $62

  • Veal Chop Pepperoni Parmigiana

    burrata mozzarella

    $63

  • Veal Chop Milanese

    tomatoes, basil, arugula

    $62

Download PDF


Three Courses - $39.95 per person

Available Mon-Fri Lunch

First Course

  • Caprese Salad with Housemade Burrata

    heirloom tomato, basil

  • Little Gem Caesar Salad

  • Italian Wedding Soup

    chicken sausage meatball

  • Smoked Salmon Bruschetta

    challah bread, capers, red onion, creme fraiche

  • Fried Calamari

    hot cherry peppers

  • Cauliflower Milanese

    fiorello hummus

  • Short Rib Meatballs (2)

Main Course

  • Mediterranean Branzino

    perla's lemon spinach

    supp $7

  • Petit Dover Sole

    perla's lemon spinach

    supp $10

  • Chicken Cobb Salad

    avocado, bacon blue cheese, tomato, egg

  • Orecchiette with Sausage and Broccoli Rabe

  • Rigatoni alla Vodka

    guanciale bacon, bread crumbs

  • Margherita Pizza

    burrata mozzarella, pomodoro, basil

  • A lot of Pepperoni Pizza

    'nduja sausage, spicy honey

  • Our Famous Chicken Parmigiana

    burrata mozzarella

  • chicken picatta

    artichoke, capers, beurre blanc

  • Herbed Chicken Paillard

    marilena salad or caesar salad

Dessert

  • Petit Chocolate Mousse & Whipped Cream

  • Tiramisu

    espresso & marscapone cream

  • Ice Cream

    choice of vanilla bean, strawberry or chocolate

BRUNCH

Download PDF

Brunch Cocktails

  • SBAGLIATO SPRITZ

    campari, sweet vermouth, prosecco, orange

    $15.50

  • MIMOSA

    $15

  • BELLINI

    $15

  • BLOODY MARY

    $15

Eggs & Omelets

served with cacio e pepe fries
egg whites available upon request

  • Scrambled Eggs

    scrambled eggs $20

    applewood smoked bacon $23

    housemade italian sausage $22

    eastern nova smoked salmon $25

  • gooey cheese omelet

    cheddar, parmesan, mozzarella

    $22

  • sausage & broccolini omelet

    cheddar cheese

    $23

  • avocado toast & poached eggs

    challah bread, pumpkin seeds, salad

    $26

    add eastern nova smoked salmon $12

    add prosciutto $9

  • additional croissant, everything bagel, or gluten free toast

    $5

Breakfast Specialties

  • Artichoke Frittata Omelet

    crispy shallots, parmigiano, pecorino

    $28

  • Smoked Salmon Omelet

    everything bagel served with cream cheese, caramelized onions

    $30

  • eastern nova smoked salmon bagel board

    everything bagel served with cream cheese, bibb lettuce, cucumber, tomato, onions and capers

    $24

  • Home Run Breakfast

    one classic buttermilk pancake, scrambled eggs, italian sausage, applewood smoked bacon, cacio e pepe fries

    $30

French Toast & Pancakes

  • tony bennett’s french toast

    strawberries, pecans, all-natural maple syrup

    $24

  • classic buttermilk pancakes

    strawberry compote, all-natural maple syrup

    $24

  • blueberry buttermilk pancakes

    blueberry compote, all-natural maple syrup

    $24.95

  • toasted hazelnut maple pancakes

    mascarpone cream, hazelnut sauce

    $24.95

  • Banana-Pecan Pancakes

    $25.95

Energy Bowls

  • greek yogurt bowl

    blueberries, strawberry

    $15

  • greek yogurt & granola bowl

    blueberries, strawberry

    $17

Sides

  • applewood smoked bacon

    $11

  • Mortadella

    $10

  • Housemade Italian Sausage

    $11

  • Eastern Nova Smoked Salmon

    $14

  • Cacio e Pepe French Fries

    $13

  • everything bagel & cream cheese

    bibb lettuce, cucumber, tomato, onion, capers

    $15

  • Additional Bread

    croissant, everything bagel, or gluten free toast

    $5

Vegetable Antipasto Bar

available after 12 pm
three vegetables $28 | five vegetables $38

  • cauliflower milanese

    herb breaded cauliflower

  • sicilian eggplant caponata

    tomato, capers, olives, raisins

  • Puff Pastry Vegetable Tart

    seasonal veggies & ricotta cheese

  • Roasted Brussels Sprouts

    parmigiano cheese

  • Stuffed Peppers

    capers, olives, and tuscan bread

  • Fava Bean Salad

  • Sausage & Peppers

  • mushroom trifolati

    oyster, portobello, crimini, garlic

  • roasted heirloom carrots

    roasted honey thyme glaze

  • marinated olives & shaved parmigiano

  • Ricotta Cheese Balls

    pomodoro sauce

  • Truffle Potato Pie

  • Stuffed Artichoke

    herbed breadcrumb

  • arancini

    risotto, parmigiano, and mushroom

  • grilled asparagus

  • Butternut Squash Lasagna

Whole Loaf Bread

  • plain loaf

    $6

  • garlic spread

    $10

  • Truffle Spread

    $12

Specialty Appetizers

  • Tomato-Goat Cheese Bruschetta

    $18

  • Italian Wedding Soup

    chicken sausage meatball

    $18

  • short rib meatballs

    two $12

    four $20

  • Sausage & Peppers

    $17

  • fried artichokes alla giudia

    $26

  • Fried Calamari

    hot cherry pepper

    $20

  • Crab Cakes

    lemon aioli

    $20

Salads & Specialty

add: chicken paillard $15, grilled shrimp $16, grilled salmon $19

  • Caprese Salad with Housemade Burrata Mozzarella

    avocado, tomato, basil

    $19

  • Quinoa & Avocado Salad

    orange, cucumber, dried currants, almonds

    $19

  • Little Gem Caesar

    brioche croutons

    $19.50

  • Marilena Salad

    truffle cheese, grapes, walnut, arugula, romaine, radicchio

    $19.50

  • prosciutto san daniele

    with burrata

    $25

  • chicken cobb salad

    $34

Entrées

  • Faroe Island Salmon

    sicilian ratatouille crust, spinach

    $39

  • Petit Dover Sole

    lemon beurre blanc, asparagus

    $39

  • Shrimp Scampi

    tuscan beans, arugula, bacon

    $37

  • black label cheeseburger

    tillamook cheddar cheese, cacio e pepe fries

    $28

  • chicken pepperoni parmigiana

    housemade burrata mozzarella, guanciale breadcrumbs

    $38

  • veal cutlet parmigiana

    housemade burrata mozzarella

    $41

Pizza

gluten-free pizza crust $6.00

  • margherita

    burrata mozzarella, pomodoro, basil

    $28

  • A lot of pepperoni

    'nduja sausage, spicy honey

    $30

  • Alla Vodka

    Vodka Sauce, Fiore di Latte

    $30

  • four seasons

    mushroom, artichoke, roasted pepper, pesto

    $30

  • prosciutto di parma

    arugula, fennel, parmesan, burrata mozzarella

    $30

  • sweet fennel sausage & roasted peppers

    burrata mozzarella

    $30

  • Diavola Pizza

    $31

Pasta

whole wheat pasta or gluten-free pasta available

  • Orecchiette with Sausage and Broccoli Rabe

    $29

  • rigatoni alla vodka

    guanciale bacon, breadcrumbs

    $29

  • fettuccine bolognese

    meat ragu

    $29

  • Spaghetti & Short Rib Meatballs

    $30

  • Housemade Ravioli Stuffed with Burrata

    pomodoro, basil

    $28

  • Linguini Pescatore

    mussels, clams, shrimp, scallops, calamari, lobster tomato broth

    $44

  • NEW Fiorello Lasagna

    shortrib beef, meatball, burrata

    $39

  • strozzapreti al pesto

    $28

Download PDF

House-Made Desserts

Download PDF

  • Chef Daniele's Famous Gelato

    vanilla bean, chocolate, pistachio, or chef's special flavor of the day

    single scoop $5.75

    3 scoops $15

  • Chocolate Mousse & Whipped Cream

    $17

  • Tiramisu Cup

    espresso & mascarpone cream

    $16

  • Housemade Cheesecake

    with fresh strawberries & warm chocolate sauce

    $17

  • Lemon Pie

    lemon curd

    $15

  • Fiorello's Tartufo

    chocolate & vanilla bean gelato rolled in chocolate chunks

    $16

  • Almond Tuille Cannolis

    two on a plate with your choice of...
    ricotta cream or pistachio cream filling

    $16

Planning an event? Let Café Fiorello bring the flavors of Italy to your table! Browse our catering menu to find the perfect dishes for your gathering.

Have questions or special requests? Email sholmes@thefiremangroup.com — if there’s something you’d like but don’t see on the menu, let us know and we’ll do our best to make it happen!

Download PDF

Email Signup

Please check errors in the form above
Thank you for signing up for email updates!
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Reservations

Please check errors in the form above
Thanks!
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.